# Review rubric

Review **records**, not the appearance of videos. No video files are included.

本次核對的是記錄字段，不是成片畫面。

## Required fields and rules

- Every shot: `aspect_ratio` must be `9:16`.
- Every shot: `duration_seconds` must be exactly `5`.
- Every shot: `product_consistent` must be `yes`.
- S03 only: `ending_text_seconds` must be at least `2`.
- A blank required field is missing information. Never fill it by guessing.

## Status priority

1. **needs_revision**: at least one known field fails a rule. If other fields are also missing, list those too; the known failure takes priority.
2. **needs_information**: no known failure, but at least one required field is missing.
3. **record_pass**: all required fields satisfy the rules. This is not final visual approval.

已知不合格優先標為需修改；沒有已知失敗但缺字段，標為信息不足；所有必需字段滿足才是記錄合格。

The ending-text field is a requirement for S03 only. A zero there does not fail S01 or S02.

## Overall project readiness

Each of S01, S02 and S03 needs at least one `record_pass` candidate. Otherwise the record-level plan is incomplete. Even if the plan were complete, a person would still need to inspect actual videos and approve the final release.

逐鏡頭檢查，不要把部分候選合格誤寫成整個項目可以交付。